1dThe Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Remake Is Already Running Rampant on PC — but Can Nintendo Do Anything About It?
Shortly after the release of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake, players quickly found ways to start playing it on PC. This was done through a few different methods. One is through an emulator, whereas others are through recompilation tools, which run the game natively on PC without emulating the Switch 2. Either way, the people who make these emulators and tools insist that users have to supply their own game files, so the downloads won’t work on their own. In other words, they want you to buy the game before you start playing it on PC, to cover their backs. This is nothing new for a big release, but we’ve never seen it done so quickly before. That’s because many of these emulators and tools were AI-assisted, which is also why you have seen so many other “native” PC ports of games floating around (to mixed results — and fears concerning how safe they actually are to play). But it’s these PC ports of Ocarina of Time that have gotten the most attention. Some players have even managed to get an unofficial multiplayer release going, mere days after the game launched on PC. There’s a lot to say about these, but debates over quality or AI usage aside, the most obvious question is: will Nintendo put up with this? The company is notoriously litigious and has successfully sued emulators before. It even started taking down Nintendo Switch 2 emulators earlier this month, so many would assume that it is only a matter of time until it does something about the Ocarina of Time craze. However, according to legal experts speaking with IGN, it won’t be a clear-cut case for Nintendo. “The basic arrangement of the emulator as just being a piece of software capable of running games that you have to provide separately is critical,” Kirk Sigmon, founding partner at KellDann Law, told IGN. “At least in theory, the law is very favorable towards emulators.” He went on to cite a case from 2000 in which Sony unsuccessfully sued the creator of an original PlayStation emulator. “[This case] basically indicates that emulators are (on their own) legal and the reverse engineering of game consoles can also be legal, even when performed in a manner that might otherwise arguably infringe copyright law,” he argued. This could apply to all the tools being used to play the Ocarina of Time remake on PC, including the popular new emulator, Lichii. “If it was developed using AI and without stealing trade secrets, and if it’s carefully managed to never include Nintendo’s other IP, it’ll be hard to stop,” Sigmon said. Others, such as Zohaib Hashim, CEO of Blackmont Legal, echoed this sentiments. “I do not believe that [emulator/decompilation creators] can be said to be breaching copyright or infringing on Nintendo's IP simply by virtue of developing and supplying emulator software,” Hashim said in an interview. “Emulators generally are legal; there's established case law going back many years supporting this,” he continued, citing the same Sony lawsuit. With that said, Sigmon admitted that Nintendo won’t take this lying down. “Nintendo is absolutely going to try to shut Lichii and/or the decompilation teams down,” he predicted. “Nintendo is likely looking for any possible justification for going after them: the accidental use of some art/music asset, the inadvertent use of a logo, evidence that they stole some sort of trade secret, or the like. “There’s even a possibility that they’ll try to shut them down for orthogonally related activities, like uploading videos of emulated game content on YouTube. After all, some gamers are already enjoying the Ocarina of Time remake on their computers mere days after the game was released. That can’t be good for the game’s sales targets.” Just days after we spoke, Nintendo started to get videos showing the Ocarina of Time remake PC port removed from YouTube over copyright claims. Other experts I spoke to highlighted possible flaws in the creators’ defence. Michael Dilworth, managing partner of Dilworth IP LLC, said that insisting users supply their own game “only gets them so far.” “Emulation itself is not inherently unlawful under U.S. copyright law,” Dilworth said. “The more difficult issue involves the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), which restricts the circumvention of technological protections and the distribution of certain circumvention technologies.” In other words, Nintendo could dive into how these tools work, rather than solely complain about the fact that the emulator exists at all. “Nintendo relied heavily on that statute in its case against Yuzu, and its recent enforcement activity suggests that circumvention remains central to its legal strategy,” Dilworth said. What About The People Using The Emulator? On the whole, it seems to be agreed that those operating emulators or recompilation tools have a decent defence, so what about the people using them? That’s where we see a difference in opinion. I raised the point with Sigmon that Switch 2 users have to sign an end-user licence agreement (EULA), which could be breached by decompiling legitimately purchased projects. He did not feel that Nintendo had a leg to stand on here. “That’s just words on a page that Nintendo would have to try to actually enforce in a court or some sort of arbitration tribunal,” Sigmon said. “Such enforcement would introduce a lot of hurdles — for example, it’s possible that someone might buy a Nintendo Switch 2 and use it for reverse engineering purposes without ever agreeing to Nintendo’s EULA.” However, Hashim came at this issue from another angle.